How to Legally Protect Your Business When Hiring Industry Talent

Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer, but I’ve spent enough on legal fees to know when you should call one. Everything here is from experience and cautionary tales, not a substitute for actual legal advice. But trust me: you do not want to learn these lessons the hard way.

Hiring Isn’t Just HR, It’s a Legal Minefield

Hiring a new employee should feel exciting. You’re growing. You’re expanding. You’re finally getting help.

But in today’s legal climate, every new hire brings risk. Especially when they’re coming from another business in your space.

If you’re not checking non-competes, non-solicits, and confidentiality agreements, or having new hires sign your own, you could be exposing your business to lawsuits, bad press, and financial pain before the new hire even sets up their inbox.

This post will walk you through:

• What non-compete and non-solicit agreements actually mean
• How to review them before hiring
• What happens if you don’t
• How to protect your business (with actual documents and checklists)
• And why you should never, ever skip legal onboarding

Let’s Start with the Horror Story

A few years ago, we hired someone from a competing business.

They were sharp. Eager. Knew the industry inside and out.

We asked if they were under a non-compete.
They said, “Not really.”
We didn’t ask for a copy.
They started work on Monday.

By Wednesday, we had a letter from their old employer’s lawyer accusing us of:

• Poaching talent
• Inducing a breach of contract
• Interfering with business relationships

The employee, it turns out, had signed a detailed non-compete covering our entire region, industry, and client base. We were now in violation simply by hiring them.

The fallout?

• Tens of thousands in legal fees
• Temporary restraining order (TRO)
• An employee we had to “pause” before they’d even passed probation
• Months of sleepless nights

Chapter 1: What Is a Non-Compete Agreement?

A non-compete agreement (NCA) is a clause or contract that prevents an employee from working for a competing business for a certain time period and within a certain geographical area after leaving their job.

Typical features of a non-compete:

• A defined term (e.g. 6 months, 1 year, 2 years)
• A defined geographic scope (e.g. “within 100 miles” or “anywhere in the U.S.”)
• A defined industry or business scope
• Language that prevents indirect competition (e.g. consulting, advising, launching your own business)

Even if a non-compete feels broad or unreasonable, it’s still a legal document, and it can be enforced unless successfully challenged.

Bottom line:
If you hire someone who’s under a valid non-compete, and you don’t do your homework, you could be the one footing the legal bill.

Chapter 2: What’s a Non-Solicit (and Why It Might Be Worse)?

A non-solicitation agreement often gets lumped in with non-competes but deserves its own spotlight.

It prevents a former employee from:

• Recruiting their old coworkers to join your company
• Poaching clients from their old employer
• Using contacts and relationships they gained while at the previous job

You might think this only applies to big corporate hires or executive-level roles. Not true.

Many small businesses include these clauses for account managers, salespeople, tech support staff, and even admin roles; anyone with exposure to proprietary systems or clients.

If you’re not checking for non-solicits before hiring, you might accidentally invite:

• A client poaching lawsuit
• Claims of interference with business relationships
• A mess your insurance may not even cover

Chapter 3: “They Said They Didn’t Sign Anything” Is Not a Defense

Here’s the hard truth:
People don’t always remember what they signed. And sometimes, they don’t tell the truth.

An employee might say:

• “It was just a generic form.”
• “I don’t think it’s enforceable.”
• “That was years ago.”
• “I never got a copy.”

You know who does have a copy?
Their former employer.
And that’s the person who will send it, directly to your lawyer, with a very angry cover letter attached.

Chapter 4: What to Do Before You Hire Anyone from a Competitor

Before you extend that offer letter, run through this checklist:

✅ Ask Directly

“Are you currently under any non-compete, non-solicitation, or confidentiality agreements with your previous employer?”

Don’t skip this question. Make it part of your standard interview process.

✅ Request a Copy

If the answer is yes (or “I think so”), ask for the document.

If they don’t have it, pause the hiring process until they can get one. Don’t proceed on guesswork.

✅ Have Your Lawyer Review It

Even if it seems vague or overreaching, let your legal counsel make that call. Some agreements are enforceable. Others aren’t. It varies by state, industry, and specific wording.

✅ Document the Discussion

Keep a written record of what the employee disclosed and when. If legal action happens later, you’ll want a paper trail showing you acted in good faith.

Chapter 5: Your Legal Onboarding Checklist

Once you’ve confirmed they’re clear to work, you need your own protections in place.

Here’s what you should have every new hire sign:

1. Confidentiality Agreement

Outlines what they can’t share outside the company (or with future employers). Covers trade secrets, client lists, financials, internal docs, and more.

2. IP Assignment Agreement

Clarifies that anything created during their employment (designs, code, copy, etc.) belongs to your business, not them personally.

3. Employee Release of Prior Confidentiality Obligations

This one’s huge, and often missed.

It’s a short agreement where the employee confirms:

• They are not bringing any proprietary information from a former employer
• They agree not to use or share anything protected
• They understand your company prohibits the use of any stolen or restricted data

This document helps prove that you made good faith efforts to avoid legal conflicts and respect previous agreements.

4. Acknowledgement of Company Policies

Include your handbook, if you have one, or a signed statement saying they’ve reviewed your company’s basic policies.

Chapter 6: What Happens If You Skip This

Let’s say you don’t ask the right questions. You don’t check their documents. You bring them on board and everything seems fine.

Until it’s not.

You might face:

• A cease-and-desist letter from a former employer
• A lawsuit for breach of contract or tortious interference
• Client loss if relationships get entangled in legal drama
• Reputational damage within your industry
• The cost of firing or benching an employee you just invested in

Even if you win, you’ll spend thousands defending yourself. And if you lose, you may have to pay damages, legal fees, and more.

Chapter 7: The Long-Term Benefits of Doing It Right

When you screen thoroughly and onboard legally, you build:

• Trust within your team
• Credibility in your industry
• Protection from high-risk scenarios
• A repeatable process that scales with growth

Hiring doesn’t have to be a legal nightmare. But it will be if you pretend the risks aren’t real.

Chapter 8: A Note on Remote Hires and Multi-State Teams

If you're hiring across state lines, especially in remote or hybrid roles, the legal landscape gets even trickier.

• Some states (like California) ban non-competes almost entirely.
• Others (like Florida or Texas) are much more aggressive in enforcement.
• If your employee lives in one state, your business is based in another, and the client is elsewhere, that’s a three-way legal tangle.

Work with a lawyer who understands employment law in all relevant states.
Generic templates don’t cut it when geography affects legality.

Chapter 9: Sample Release Language You Should Use (and Customize)

Here’s a basic release you can have your lawyer adapt:

“I, [Employee Name], certify that I am not in possession of or using any confidential, proprietary, or trade secret information from any previous employer in my role at [Your Company Name]. I understand that I am prohibited from disclosing or using any such information, and I agree to indemnify and hold harmless [Your Company Name] from any claims arising from my previous employment agreements.”

Short. Simple. Enforceable. I must say it again, IANAL (I am not a lawyer). This is not legal advice.

Chapter 10: The Legal Hat Is Heavy, But You Need to Wear It

You don’t need to be a full-time legal expert.
But you do need to protect your business from legal fallout before it starts.

Too many small businesses treat hiring like a handshake deal, and find themselves in court because of it.

By checking non-competes, reviewing old agreements, and putting your own documents in place, you create a safer, smarter business that grows without chaos.

The legal hat might not be fun. But ignoring it is far more expensive.

Want More Posts Like This?